mix150.com MIX150 DOWNLOAD GAMES PLAYSTATION RIP FILMS
‏إظهار الرسائل ذات التسميات Problem. إظهار كافة الرسائل
‏إظهار الرسائل ذات التسميات Problem. إظهار كافة الرسائل

الثلاثاء، 14 أغسطس 2012

How to Answer a New Zealand Bill of Rights Act Discrimination Problem Question

The issue is whether [facts] constitute discrimination against [person] under s 19 of BORA.

Section 19 is designed to ensure people are not treated differently unfairly, a core feature of a society based on democracy and freedom where each individual is valued as a person, worthy of dignity and respect.

The NZ Courts (Northern Regional Health Authority) have adopted a two-step approach to analyzing s 19, firstly establishing a prima facie breach of s 19 and then adopting a s 5 analysis to see if the breach is justified.

Law v Canada adopts an alternative 'purpose' approach, I will not follow that as the New Zealand HC in Atkinson distinguished that approach as (a) BORA has no guarantee of equality analogous to s 15(1) of the Canadian Charter (b) S 20L(2) of the HRA indicates a two step approach (c) S 21 of the HRA does not indicate any evaluative process However, the contextual factor discussion in Law and it's focus on dignity forms part of the s 5 analysis.

STEP 1 - IS IT DISCRIMINATION UNDER S19?

"Differential Treatment..."

In order to find Prima Facie discrimination under s 19 [person] must first establish a differential treatment or effect, that is either;

• A formal distinction based on a personal characteristic.
• A failure to take into account an existing disadvantage which has the effect of differential treatment.

Differential treatment must be identified as compared to finding a similarly situated comparator group. (Wilson, affirmed in NZ in NRHA). NOTE Natural starting point is that the claimants view is not always sufficient. The Court can't invent a group but can refine Law.

Therefore this reg/act has the effect of differential treatment.

"...on a prohibited ground..."

By virtue of BORA s 19(1) any ground of discrimination in the Human Rights Act 1993 is a prohibited ground. This reg/act discriminates on the ground of HRA s?? as [APPLICATION] NOTE INDIRECT s 65 - NHRA affirmed that broad approach required focusing on effect.

"...that disadvantages the complainant..."

This not limited to the motive but is a discriminatory impact, NHRA. Law v Canada places an emphasis on substantive discrimination based on the concept of dignity. CONTEXTUAL FACTORS - Law (a) Pre-existing disadvantage, incl stereotyping (if furthering stereotype enough for prima facie) (b) Historic disadvantage - important but not determinative, no presumption diff treatment is discriminatory (c) Don't need to establish a sociologically recognized group (d) No presumption that diff treatment is discrimination (e) Not disadvantaging if advantaging another group and if you are more advantaged relatively.

Positive Discrimination - Hugo Cannot achieve the goal of a fair society by insisting on equal treatment Look at policy considerations Can't complain not given an advantage to which you have no right

Dissent - Kriegler J Need to be based on factual circumstances not conjecture Blunt axe approach not appropriate Can serve to increase discrimination by reinforcing stereotypes

[Name] has been disadvantaged in that [App]

STEP 2 - LIMIT ON RIGHTS JUSTIFIED UNDER S 5?

The most recent and authoritative statement on s 5 is the modified Oakes test enumerated by Tipping J in Hansen. Tipping J notes that Parliament must be afforded a 'margin of appreciation' which will vary according to context.

Administrators have an understanding of issues Courts can't achieve, (Atkinson).

OAKES TEST

1. Does the limiting measure serve a purpose sufficiently important to justify curtailment of the right or freedom? (Threshold Issue)

McGrath J describes these as concerns that are pressing and substantial in a free and democratic society, Hansen This approach mirrors the 'good reason' in NHRA. APPLICATION Good reason- Reasonableness, not just economic necessity. Body must justify themselves Genuine need NHRA

2. (i) is the limiting measure rationally connected with its purpose? (Threshold issue)

(ii) does the limiting measure impair the right or freedom as little as possible? (Proportionality issue)

(iii) is the limit proportional to the importance of the objective? (Proportionality issue)

Conclusion

For a Regulation

In Drew the Courts invoked the presumption of consistency in finding that an empowering legislation implied that any regulation made under it must be consistent with BORA. I believe that this principle is likely to be applied here and the Courts would find [reg] ultra vires of [statute] and thus having no legal effect.

Or, for a Statute

Apply Hansen

Is there another meaning available on the language of the text? s6 of NZBORA

If not, then apply s 4.

This workshop was produced by Arthur Denning at Law Notes New Zealand

If you would like to learn more please visit http://www.lawnotes.co.nz/


View the original article here

الثلاثاء، 8 مايو 2012

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Is a Significant Health Problem Today

While industrial jobs are hard to find in this economy, service-based roles have increased, causing more employees to suffer from Carpal Tunnel Syndrome, a painful disorder that is discomforting and sometimes there can be numbness of the hands. Carpal Tunnel Syndrome is at the forefront of the new workplace and a significant health problem today. Because Carpal Tunnel Syndrome is a common workplace injury, it is considered to be a worker's compensation claim and there are many workers compensation questions surrounding it.

What is Carpal Tunnel Syndrome?
Carpal Tunnel Syndrome (CTS) is a Repetitive Stress Injury (RSI). CTS occurs when wrists are exposed to persistent and repetitive strain. The tissues surrounding the tendons become so enlarged that they compress the median nerve, which runs through the carpal tunnel, a passage in the wrist. CTS can cause the following symptoms though they can be different for everyone:

· Numbness, tingling and pain in the hand, wrist and forearm
· Impaired or lost nerve function
· Reduced muscle control
· Reduced grip strength

What are the causes?
Causes can include working hour after hour at a computer keyboard, meat cutting and wrapping, high speed assembly-line work, or any other activity where the hand and fingers are employed in repetitive motions for extended periods of time. Repeated motions performed in the course of normal work or other daily activities can result in repetitive motion disorders such as carpal tunnel syndrome.

Is Carpal Tunnel Syndrome considered a work-related injury under the Illinois Workers' Compensation Act?
Yes, the Illinois Supreme Court has said that because Carpal Tunnel Syndrome develops gradually and is not as the result of a sudden accident, employees can be compensated from the onset of Carpal Tunnel Syndrome under the Act.

What medical benefits am I entitled to after I develop Carpal Tunnel at work?
For workers compensation claims you are entitled to receive 100% of all medical expenses that are reasonable and necessary to treat your condition. These include, but are not limited to, emergency room services, doctors' visits, inpatient and outpatient hospital care, and prescriptions.

What wage benefits am I entitled to while I am off work because of my CTS?
For workers compensation claims you are entitled to temporary total disability compensation (TTD) while you are off work and are under active medical treatment. Temporary total disability compensation is based on a percentage of your average weekly wage, including overtime.

Will I be entitled to receive any other benefits after I return to work at my regular job after being treated for Carpal Tunnel Syndrome?
You may be entitled to receive compensation for the partial permanent loss of use of your hands or arms as a result of contracting CTS while on the job. Such compensation is called permanent partial disability compensation (PPD), and is received as the result of a settlement agreement between you and your employer, or as the result of the decision of the arbitrator assigned to your claim.

Who is at risk of developing Carpal Tunnel Syndrome?
Women are three times more likely than men to develop CTS, typically because wrist bones are naturally smaller in most women, creating a tighter space through which the nerves and tendons pass. The dominant hand is usually affected first and produces the most severe pain. The risk of developing Carpal Tunnel Syndrome is not confined to a single industry or job, but is common among assembly line work such as manufacturing, sewing, finishing, cleaning, and meat, poultry, or fish packing. CTS is three times more common among assemblers than among data-entry personnel.

Can CTS be prevented?
At the workplace, workers can do on-the-job conditioning, perform stretching exercises, take frequent rest breaks, wear splints to keep wrists straight, and use correct posture and wrist position. Wearing fingerless gloves can help keep hands warm and flexible. Workstations, tools, tool handles, and tasks can be redesigned to enable the worker's wrist to maintain a natural position during work.

Howard Ankin founded the Ankin Law Office LLC over 12 years ago; the firm is known and respected as one of Chicago's top Workers' Compensation and Personal Injury Law practices. With extensive experience practicing personal injury, workers compensation, wrongful death, social security disability, and criminal and civil litigation, Howard has devoted his professional life to seeking justice on behalf of his clients and providing superior legal support for all of its clients.

Howard Ankin prides himself in representing his clients as their friend and attorney, often providing quality referrals for legal matters outside of his practice areas. His investment in the Ankin Law Office LLC is evidenced every day as families throughout the Chicago area and Illinois return to the firm for legal guidance at all stages of their lives.

If you need legal representation, please contact Ankin Law Offices LLC (howardankin@ankinlaw.com) and let us walk you through the legal landscape in a free one-hour confidential consultation. We will listen to you. Our personal injury, workers compensation, and motor vehicle accident lawyers give clients straightforward legal advice and a clear understanding of the legal steps we will follow in resolving your legal issues.


View the original article here

المشاركات الشائعة